Spotlight Café & Creamery

802 9th St, Greeley, CO 80631, United States
+1 970-836-2646
$$$ Cafe
(24 Reviews)
Price Range $1–10

Welcome to Spotlight Café & Creamery, an inviting gem nestled in downtown Greeley, Colorado at 802 9th St. This lovely café marries a modern vibe with a vintage ice cream parlor charm, making it the perfect spot for coffee lovers, breakfast enthusiasts, and anyone with a sweet tooth.

Step inside, and you will be greeted by a warm, cozy atmosphere adorned with a plethora of plants that add a touch of life and brightness. The decor is stylish yet comfortable, featuring well-maintained tables and cushy seating options that create an inviting space to work, unwind, or catch up with friends. As one customer, Rob Web, beautifully puts it, the café offers a “warm and beautiful” environment that is clean and thoughtfully designed.

At Spotlight, every bite and sip is a celebration. Begin your day with a delightful bagel, customized to your liking with their B.Y.O. Bagel Sandwich for just $4.95, or indulge in the savory Ham & Cheese Melt or Sausage Egg & Cheese for a satisfying start to your morning. The Pesto Turkey Delight, beautifully merges creamy, herby flavors with tender turkey nestled in your choice of bagel—a must-try for any bagel lover!

And let’s not forget the drinks! The café boasts an impressive menu of specialty lattes guaranteed to awaken your taste buds. Sip on the crowd-favorite Nasty Cluster Latte with rich hazelnut, almond, and chocolate flavors or try the Mexican Mocha Latte spiced with cocoa, cinnamon, nutmeg, and just a touch of cayenne pepper for that extra kick. Each drink is crafted with care, ensuring a delicious experience from the first sip until the last.

Juliette Shine described her experience perfectly, noting that everything about the place is “cozy and wonderful”, and it’s impossible not to feel uplifted by the cheerful and friendly staff who are always eager to make recommendations and ensure you have a fantastic visit.

The beauty of Spotlight Café & Creamery doesn’t stop at coffee and bagels. Their handcrafted ice creams are an unmissable treat, offering a delightful way to cool down after a long day or celebrate a special moment with a sweet indulgence. Whether it’s a classic cone or a unique creation, you’re bound to find something that makes your heart sing.

Spotlight Café & Creamery isn't just a place to grab your daily caffeine fix; it's an experience that enriches your day. Join the community of satisfied locals and visitors who have made it their go-to spot in Greeley, and discover a new favorite in every cup.

Call them at +1 970-836-2646 to learn more or stop by and see for yourself what makes this café so special!

Service options
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Popular for
Breakfast
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Breakfast
Catering
Dessert
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Quiet
Trendy
Crowd
University students
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
NFC mobile payments
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Tuesday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Wednesday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Thursday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Friday

07:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Saturday

08:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Sunday

08:00 AM - 07:00 PM

24 Reviews
Jeremy Yachik

06 Oct 2025

This place is absolutely wonderful. They have awesome breakfast burritos from bandit burrito. They are very reasonably priced. The coffee is outstanding and it's close to the courthouse, so anybody working at the courthouse has a close place to get coffee again. The staff is wonderful, very friendly, very knowledgeable, super helpful. They did a wonderful job with this place. I can't wait to see how their menu expands.

Gilly Shine

17 Sep 2025

Everything about this place is cozy and wonderful. The staff is friendly, and they have a lot of plants. We came in for coffee and obviously had to get these danishes. What a lovely addition to downtown Greeley!

Christie M

08 Sep 2025

What a vibe! It's modern coffee shop meets vintage ice cream parlor! Excellent baked goods, delicious ice cream, cool and kind staff, and Properly made coffee drinks that are great!

Jacob Villa

12 Aug 2025

First time trying this coffee shop. And I am so excited to have a place like this in Greeley. The latte was amazing as well as a unique drink My wife got called “Fogotto” (it had ice cream in it.) definitely come try it. Service is also amazing.

Rob Web

13 Jul 2025

this is a warm and beautiful cafe. the decor is first rate, the chairs are comfortable and the tables clean. they have a number of seating options from a high top to larger tables and even some window seats. I had a dirty chai and was pleasantly surprised by their in house made chai (a little spicy). I also tried one of their bagel sandwiches (pesto turkey) and it was wonderful. the wait staff were super friendly and nice and I instantly felt welcome. open till 10p as well which is a rare coffee place.

April Rogers

11 Jul 2025

I’m having dessert before lunch today at Spotlight! First, a cinnamon ice cream espresso affogato, then my chipotle turkey on a bagel-both a terrific treat! It’s across from Doug’s Diner and next to the Moxi in Greeley, CO. Now they have “Boozy Drinks”-next time I’m trying the Irish Coffee Milkshake!

Victoria Everett

04 Jul 2025

The chocolate cookie and ice-cream is a pleasant surprise to find on the menu! It’s sooooo delicious! If you’re undecided on what to get for a drink Sarah can definitely give you the best recommendations and make it perfectly to your liking!

Jennifer R.

13 Jun 2025

This was the first time we got food here and it was delicious!! I got a bagel sandwich with ham, egg, and cheese. It has a side salad of greens that I put on as well. My husband got the breakfast burrito. To drink he got a cold brew and I got the berries and cream coffee. Everything was delicious! The first time we went we got ice cream and coffee. I got the cinnamon ice cream. Omg, to die for! I want a carton of it! The atmosphere is really chill and nice. Service is super friendly and nice. If you're in the are you should check this place out!

Join the Spotlight Café & Creamery Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.